Episode 26

When Love Isn’t Enough - With Katya Lidsky

Loving our pets is absolutely fundamental to making your pet partnership work. And yes, it is work a lot of the time.

Bringing a new animal home to your existing pets can be a tough thing to get right. It can take a lot of time, energy, and effort, so loving them is a big part of staying sane and keeping everyone happy.

But sometimes, love isn’t enough.

There’s bound to be a little tension, but with a lot of work, training, patience, and management strategies, that should all pay off. But sometimes, it just doesn’t. You might have tried every tactic under the sun to help everyone get along, and it still might not work.  

In a coaching call, I spoke with Katya Lidsky, animal lover, writer, and host of The Animal That Changed You podcast. We talked about her experience with fostering animals over the years and about the time she made the tough call to rehome a kitten to keep the peace with her other animals. Tune in to hear why it was the right call to make in Katya’s case.

Key Moments

6:43 – Katya talks about her experience of fostering animals

12:01 – Why cats react differently when coming home from a shelter

14:39 – Why you should aim for two layers of management between pets

17:18 – How Katya dealt with a difficult dynamic between two pets

21:25 – Why sometimes making a tough decision to rehome a pet is best

25:12 – How to know when to rehome vs. stick at it and continue training

27:09 – Using data to objectively look at conflict

36:15 – How to assess the effects difficult animals have on our health and family

39:55 – What a healthy pet coexistence looks like

44:16 – Why it’s important to make tough decisions based on your own needs

Key Links

About the Podcast

Show artwork for It's Training Cats and Dogs!
It's Training Cats and Dogs!
The podcast for cat-AND-dog people.

About your host

Profile picture for Naomi Rotenberg

Naomi Rotenberg

MA, KPA-CTP
specializing in cat and dog integration

Hi! I'm Naomi, and I'm a "cat-and-dog person" 👋 My goal with this podcast is to speak to people with multi-species households who currently feel alone. There are lots of highs and lows when trying to manage the relationships between your animals. This podcast will give you clear, actionable information and guidance about the unique issues that come up between cats and dogs. And the monthly interviews with my fellow trainers who have cats and dogs will definitely help you realize that you aren't alone!

A bit about me: I'm a certified professional dog trainer (KPA-CTP) and have my MA in Animal Behavior and Conservation. I live in my own multi-species household in Philadelphia, PA with my husband, two human kids, Uri (a mini American Eskimo Dog), and Rio (a domestic shorthair cat). I also LOVE Twizzlers (the original kind, NOT pull-and-peel).

I look forward to getting to know you and your pets on your journey towards a more peaceful and safe coexistence!